January 23, 2017 Ingredient of the month

Thermal waters in France (1/2)

© CosmeticOBS-L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques

The notion of thermal baths and thermal water-based treatments is very old: it dates back to Ancient Greece. As a guarantee of skin beauty, thermal water is flourishing in today’s cosmetics. Here is a special focus on this ingredient between skincare and beauty product.

Thermal water is an integral cosmetic ingredient, given its INCI name (Aqua, the official term to which manufacturers often add the origin of the spring), and the evidence of its benefits in the field of beauty. It is also a natural, ancestral component.

What is thermal water?

Thermal waters originate from a re-emergent spring at the surface or drilled in depth. They are devoid of any bacteria, due to the place where they can be found. So, they can be considered pure.
Thermal waters have a different composition from that of the waters intended to be consumed. They are rich in dissolved minerals and salts or trace elements. ‘It is when they fall and run through a whole series of biological layers that waters naturally get richer,' explains Jean-Claude Le Joliff, founder of La Cosmétothèque. Calcium, magnesium, zinc, and others are all elements that can enrich these waters. And yet, the substances found in thermal waters are not an issue for the skin, contrary to scale or limestone.

Are they all the same?
Although thermal waters are all composed of trace elements, they are not all the same. Their springs are different from a geographic and geological standpoint. As a result, their composition depends on the resources found where the rain falls and the richness of the soil from which they gush forth. That is why the classification of thermal waters is determined according to their total minerality, which can range from a few dozens of milligrams to several dozens of grams.

Heat and treatments
Thermal waters have another characteristic: their high temperature. From the Latin word ‘thermæ', the word thermal baths refers to the public baths in the Ancient Rome. These springs used to serve as treatment waters, as they were believed to have curative virtues. Is that just a quaint creed? Not at all, the tradition endured over the centuries. Many thermal waters are recognized today by the French Academy of Medicine for their applications and benefits for the skin. Jean-Claude Le Joliff actually explains that ‘a whole file is required to promote a spring to the Academy of Medicine, including tangible evidence and test results'.

Thermal springs in France
As the third richest European country in terms of thermal spas, France counts 108 of them, where all sorts of ailments and diseases are treated. From dermatology to child development disorders or neurological diseases, these springs offer a large range of what thermal waters can cure. Most of the time, thermal spa treatments are provided in the form of a cure that lasts a few days, and are sometimes prescribed by doctors. It should be known that the same spring can only claim a maximum of three applications to the Academy of Medicine.

Drinkable or not?
Most thermal waters are not drinkable, due to their temperature and minerality. Still, some of them can very well be consumed, like Avène thermal spring water.

From cures to cosmetics

Are thermal waters useful in beauty products?
It is a known fact that water is one of the most present ingredients in cosmetic products, in terms of quantity. Formulators used demineralized water in their products for a long time, and they still do. However, for a few years, the cosmetics industry has taken interest in the use of thermal water in cosmetics, for their renowned properties. Jean-Claude Le Joliff emphasizes the fact that ‘if it was legitimate for certain thermal waters to be used for the formulation of beauty products, others did not necessarily have any interest in skincare. That is why there is this additional work in the scientific literature to find evidence of the benefits of particular thermal waters and the need to formulate products with them,' he adds.
Avène, a brand of the Pierre Fabre group, showed the properties of spring water of the same name in the years 2000, following the discovery of a yet unknown microflora in Avène water, called Aquaphilus Dolomiae. Soon, ‘pharmacological studies (there were many of them, and they were published in international referenced journals), demonstrated that Avène thermal spring water had soothing, anti-irritant, anti-inflammatory, and antipruritic properties, both related to its mineral composition and the presence of this microflora,' explains Didier Guerrero, dermatologist and consultant of the Avène Dermatological Laboratories.
Another brand, same fight: the mayor of the city of Jonzac encouraged Eau de Jonzac, which is part of the Léa Nature group, to promote the water of their thermal baths and integrate it to cosmetics. Then, the brand endeavoured to demonstrate its benefits, and Valérie Cauche, Cosmetics Manager, explains that following the tests performed, several were found in the Eau de Jonzac. ‘We have already started focusing on skin regeneration, since that is what had been observed by our medical staff at the thermal baths. We measured the thickness of the stratum corneum and the epidermis as a whole in the presence of Jonzac thermal water. It resulted in a considerable improvement of these layers, which means the thermal water is active on the skin barrier,' Valérie Cauche underlines. The soothing, anti-inflammatory, and hypoallergenic aspects were also highlighted.

Extraction conditions
To integrate thermal water to a cosmetic product, it should be extracted from its spring. The cosmetics industry usually takes it on a punctual basis, depending on its production needs, not continuously.
Extraction methods vary according to the spring. Either it emerges, or it is a submarine spring. At Eau de Jonzac, ‘water is taken from the ground water, 1,800 metres deep, directly from the aquifer,' specifies Valérie Cauche. The extraction is carried out by drilling. On the contrary, Avène is a gushing spring water, so ‘the thermal water is extracted with two collecting pipes, in accordance with most rigorous safety standards to preserve all its qualities. These collecting pipes are directly connected to the thermal installations and production unit of Avène aerosols and dermocosmetics ranges,' Didier Guerrero reports.
When it is extracted, thermal water can be contaminated by bacteria. ‘However, ultrafiltration makes it possible to decontaminate it, without changing its composition,' Jean-Claude Le Joliff explains.

Formulation difficulties
Although its advantages for the skin have been demonstrated by scientists, thermal water is hard to formulate. To Jean-Claude Le Joliff, it is due to the fact that ‘some waters are richer in trace elements than others. For a long time, formulation systems were very sensitive to this issue. It is trickier to formulate with thermal water than demineralized water, which is why the latter can be found in most cosmetics. Thermal water is filled with metallic elements which can generate incompatibilities with the other ingredients in the composition.'
Didier Guerrero confirms this statement, specifying that ‘we are dealing with water whose composition is not as simple as that of the distilled water commonly used in cosmetics. It is not just water, it is a real active. As a result, formulating skincare products based on thermal water requires particular know-how in galenics: our formulators have been experts since the brand was founded.'

From mere sprays to most sophisticated beauty products, the ‘thermal water' wave is increasingly flowing in the cosmetics industry. Ideal both for sensitive skins and those that do not suffer from any disorder, the risk is very limited as regards the use of thermal water. At least, you are sure you are using pure water.

To be continued
Specificities of French thermal waters used in cosmeticssoon online.


© CosmeticOBS-L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques
Related articles [1]
February 1, 2017 Ingredient of the month
Thermal waters in France (2/2)

Extremely popular among major cosmetics groups, thermal waters are on a roll. Their benefits are not only useful for marketing arguments: the evidence of their properties on the skin is overwhelming. [Read more ]

Your comments

Please login to see all comments

All articles [86]
© CosmeticOBS-L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques
September 11, 2017 Ingredient of the month
Actibiome: the cosmetic ingredient that rebalances the microbiota

This novelty is launched by the ingredients supplier Codif. Thanks to the use of DNA analysis techniques, its laboratories have, for the first time in cosmetics, established a microbial imprint of the skin during a period of transient stress. They also identified and characterized the microbiota... [Read more ]

© L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques
August 20, 2017 Ingredient of the month
HICC: too allergenic – a fragrance too far!

We know it by various names, including Lyral®, but on cosmetics labels it is officially listed as Hydroxyisohexyl 3-cyclohexene carboxaldehyde. Deemed too allergenic by scientific experts, it is on the verge of being banned for use in cosmetic products in Europe. Yet we still see it... [Read more ]

© L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques
June 26, 2017 Ingredient of the month

Triclosan (2,4,4’-trichloro-2’-hydroxy-diphenylether) is an antibacterial preservative that is also used as a deodorant agent. Long criticised for its harmful effects on health and the environment, it has just been – after several evaluations by European scientific experts... [Read more ]

April 5, 2017 Ingredient of the month
So many different waters… in cosmetics!

Water usually makes up over 80% of the cosmetics formulas on the market. Today, several types of water – they are more than mere water – are used in beauty products for their recognized cosmetics virtues, or to provide a hint of exoticism. They are derived from different sources and... [Read more ]

February 1, 2017 Ingredient of the month
Thermal waters in France (2/2)

Extremely popular among major cosmetics groups, thermal waters are on a roll. Their benefits are not only useful for marketing arguments: the evidence of their properties on the skin is overwhelming. [Read more ]

© L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques
November 29, 2016 Ingredient of the month
Methylisothiazolinone and Methylchloroisothiazolinone: the story of a blacklisted chemical

These preservatives, like many others, regularly draw the attention of the cosmetics media. For several years, they have been cause for worry and the subject of alerts issued by dermatologist organizations or health authorities due to their strong allergenic potential. Now, they are targeted by... [Read more ]

© CosmeticOBS-L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques
November 8, 2016 Ingredient of the month
Alcohol in cosmetics

It is usually considered friendly and festive as a drink (if it is consumed with moderation, obviously), but can alcohol keep the same image as a cosmetic ingredient? That remains to be seen… And even if it is used a lot, both the advantages and drawbacks of its presence in our hygiene... [Read more ]

© CosmeticOBS-L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques
October 12, 2016 Ingredient of the month
A like… Retinol

It is one of the most widely used anti-aging actives, and for the longest time. But if the efficacy of retinol (or vitaminA) has never been questioned, its safety of use and skin tolerance are much more doubtful. Cosmetics brands have taken this into account… and so have regulators. [Read more ]

© L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques
July 26, 2016 Ingredient of the month
Polyethylene, a small but sticking bead

It is a cosmetic ingredient that is used in high quantities in many formulas. It has been popular for a long time for its soft feel on the skin and its modest cost, as well as for its exfoliating and film-forming properties. However, its outer beauty is now overshadowed by the inner polluting... [Read more ]

© CosmeticOBS-L'Observatoire des Cosmétiques
July 15, 2016 Ingredient of the month
Titanium dioxide

It is part of many cosmetic formulas, usually as a sunscreen or colourant. It is also involved in all controversies on its toxicity, especially when it is used in the form of nanoparticles. Titanium dioxide, as it is designated in the INCI, or TiO2 for close friends, is a widely covered... [Read more ]